16 Comments
User's avatar
Moravagine's avatar

Thank you for this. You've really put your finger on what I have been so disgusted by on Substack and its lazy Internet politics. TMR pisses me off, Ross Barkan's "neo-Romantics" essay pisses me off, and this description of the reclamation of all space for conservative white boorishness resonates powerfully. Particularly the identification of the ways that snarky and bitter writing hides reactionary impulses. I've always disliked Jessa Crispin's work, and now I see much more clearly why.

Expand full comment
Teddy (T.M.) Brown's avatar

This was really, really good.

Expand full comment
Lucie Eleanor's avatar

this is such a wonderful piece. I kept nodding as I read it. as a fiction writer I’ve noticed the same is often true in terms of whose voices are amplified at the moment, particularly in the “alt-lit” scene. thank you so much for writing!

Expand full comment
Claire's avatar

Totally agree with this especially the part about conservatives seeing their viewpoint and way of life as normal and apolitical that progressivism seems to be disruptive. You've put sentiments I've had for some time into words.

Expand full comment
Christian Belanger's avatar

Lovely essay — if you haven’t seen it, you may enjoy the very short film on Louis Riel about/by Guy Maddin, another influence on Rankin: https://vimeopro.com/drewchristie/kalakala-staff-picks/video/125580819

Expand full comment
Miri's avatar

thank you for the recommendation!

Expand full comment
Shawn Cremer's avatar

A thoughtful, excellent essay Miriam (and now I’m dying to see Universal Language)

Expand full comment
tanisha's avatar

I really appreciated this essay — and it made me think of something I read recently in The Monthly Review, “Western Marxism & Imperialism” which touched on, among other things, this intentional (or just lazy) obfuscation of reality.

And I’m adding Universal Language to my watchlist!

Expand full comment
Miri's avatar

thank you! i’m a fan of gabriel rockhill

Expand full comment
Suburban Cutie's avatar

incredible!

Expand full comment
Derek Neal's avatar

I saw the trailer for Universal Language the other day at the cinema, thought it looked interesting but was a little skeptical as I thought it was just being promoted as it’s a Canadian film (I live in Canada.) But after reading this, and having just got into Kiarostami (saw him referenced in another review) I think I’m gonna have to see it.

Expand full comment
David Camus's avatar

Brillant. Your comments about T.S. Eliot and classicism made me think, by contrast, of Albert Camus, who always believed that artists should not separate themselves from the society in which they lived. Around the same time (in 1946), he delivered his famous lecture “The Human Crisis” (also known as “The Crisis of Man”) at Columbia University, which you probably know, but if not, I'd be happy to share it with you: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Cxhliwz3HJ8Bn1t5V15-8UWLmiUdYoYa/view

Expand full comment
Tony Christini's avatar

White supremacy and plutocracy is the original cancel culture. Normalized to the Cons. Also to the establishment Libs in large degree.

Expand full comment
mitali's avatar

Thank you so much for writing this brilliant piece! Makes me feel less crazy about the acute feeling of dread I experienced while reading some of the aforementioned essays.

Expand full comment
Ramiro Blanco's avatar

"liberal consensus has shifted slowly back rightward". Until American discourse doesn't understand that liberalism is the foundation of rightward, we can't expect anything very interesting coming out from the American "left".

Expand full comment
adam's avatar

This isn't true:

"He will not tell you that American workers work longer hours under worse conditions for less money than ever before or that personal debt has skyrocketed."

In particular "than ever before" is a howler.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/AWHNONAG

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEPAINUSA672N

This data is adjusted for cost of living (the largest adjustment is shelter, it is not ignored). It is also median, indicating the precise middle of the middle class.

Personal debt has increased after COVID. Recovering after record high COVID savings rates pushed it quite low.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=WE1a

Expand full comment